Site BLOG PAGE🔎 SEARCH  Ξ INDEX  MAIN MENU  UP ONE LEVEL
 OJB's Web Site. Version 2.4. Blog Page.Location: entry2459 blog owen2 
Blog

Add a Comment   Listen to Podcast   Return to Previous Page

It Sounds Crazy

Entry 2459, on 2026-10-06 at 14:58:48 (Rating 4, Skepticism)

What I am about to say might sound crazy, and you might feel the need to ridicule me and accuse me of time wasting, but while there is some merit in that attitude, give me a chance on this, OK?

Right, so here's my secret shame: I have been debating with flat Earthers on line!

I have discussed the idea of a flat Earth briefly in several previous posts, and even wrote one (from 2007-07-02 titled "The Earth is Flat") where I presented evidence showing that it really is flat. Of course, I was just trying to make a point and don't really believe that, buy why?

Believe it or not, there are people today who think the Earth is flat, usually for religious reasons, because some interpretations of the Bible seem to imply that. As I said, I have debated some of them recently on X. You might ask why, because how can you convince someone who believes something like that? Well, I don't like to make any assumptions about reality and I like to challenge myself to disprove ideas other people have, including this.

One major problem is that there are several different versions of flat Earth theories, so any evidence against one doesn't necessarily apply to them all. And my opponents sometimes make use of that by denying they follow the version I disproved, but the points I make here apply to all theories which aren't totally insane.

And that brings me to another point: as I have often said in the past, it is impossible to prove anything about the real world with 100% certainty. I could never honestly say that I can prove the world is a sphere (or oblate spheroid or other variation on the sphere) because maybe my thoughts are being manipulated by an alien entity who is trying to mislead me. But I think there is a point where the evidence is good enough (even if it is not 100%) that it could be called proof.

Before I present some of my proof, ask yourself: how do you know the Earth is "round" (assuming you do)? Do you have proof which isn't just an assumption or the opinion of the majority of experts? Is that good enough?

Maybe the simplest and most direct (meaning I can see it myself and don't rely on anyone else) proof is the shape of the Earth's shadow during a lunar eclipse. Assume the Earth is a flat disk as it is according to many flerfs (that's a somewhat derogatory term for them), what should we see during an eclipse? Well, if all three bodies are in line and directly above and below the Earth, then we might see something similar to what we actually do see, that is a curved shadow gradually covering the Moon.

But that only works if the Moon is directly in line with the Sun and Moon. I have seen lunar eclipses where the Moon is quite low in the sky. In that case the Moon is aligned with the edge of the Earth's disk (if it existed) making its shape and the duration of the eclipse very different. That can only be reasonably explained of the Earth is a globe.

Second, there are star trails when a photo is taken from near the equator. Take a wide angle photo, long exposure of stars at night and you will see they appear to move across the sky, leaving a curved trail on the photo. Those trails seem to center on the celestial pole, which is a point in the sky above the pole of the Earth.

If the Earth was flat and the stars moved, we might expect to see this phenomenon at the north pole but not the south (there is no south pole on a flat Earth), but that photo from the equator clearly shows stars overhead moving in a straight line, and as they get nearer the poles they move in tighter circles. This can only happen on a globe.

Third, there are flight times and paths of commercial aircraft. If the Earth was flat the distance between two southern cities would be much greater than on a globe. I regularly see a flight between Sydney and Santiago fly over me here in New Zealand. On a globe Earth that flight should take about 12 hours, on a flat Earth almost three times longer. And, of course, it does take approximately 12 hours.

In addition, look at northern hemisphere flights between Europe and America. If the Earth was flat their path would be close to a straight line, but they follow a weird curve instead, because they are following a straight line on the globe which corresponds to a curve when the globe is projected onto a flat map.

Fourth, there is the Foucault pendulum. This is a large, heavy pendulum which swings freely, but the line it swings on gradually moves through a complete circle, because the Earth is moving under it. Not only that, but the rate of movement corresponds exactly to what we see on a globe Earth.

Fifth, there is the Eotvos Effect. This is something I discovered while researching this, so this is a learning experience for me too. Basically, any vehicle moving eastward weighs slightly less than one moving westward. This is because the centrifugal effect of the moving object is added to or subtracted from the Earth's rotation, and the difference agrees perfectly with a globe Earth.

Sixth, when high precision surveying is done over long distances the calculations use slight curves instead of straight lines. Confusingly, for lower precision work or over short distances, straight lines are often good enough, but that's just because the Earth is big.

Seventh, we can just look. We see the curve during high altitude flights (and NASA photos, but maybe NASA is part of the conspiracy!), although it can be subtle, and we need to be aware of the distortion of wide angle lenses and aircraft windows. But these issues can be allowed for, and that curve is there.

And ships disappearing over the horizon is another familiar proof. Flerfs like to say this is caused by atmospheric distortion, but that would tend to cause the opposite effect: disguise the disappearing ship instead of enhancing it, so that doesn't work for them either.

Finally (well I could go on all day, but let's just do one more) one of my favourite Greek philosophers, Eratosthenes, did an experiment thousands of years ago showing the Earth was a globe and even estimating its size with amazing precision. Anyone can do this experiment today, although to really prove a sphere three measurements are better than the original two.

Anyone who believes the Earth is flat might reject some of these points, but could they disprove them all? Of course not, because when debating this subject there is a certain advantage I have, which is I have the facts on my side. And remember, this is just the beginning. I could list a lot more evidence for a globe, if necessary.

Have I "converted" any flerfs away from their irrational belief? Well, none that admitted it, but maybe over a longer time period they might finally "see the light". Also any people watching the debate who might be tempted by flat Earth BS will see my arguments and realise the flat Earth is silly and this avoids the "disease" spreading. And lastly, it tests my beliefs. Is believing the Earth is a sphere actually justified? Well, yes, it certainly seems to be!


There are no comments for this entry.


You can leave comments about this entry using this form.

Enter your name (optional):
Enter your email address (optional):
Enter the number shown here:number
Enter the comment:

To add a comment: enter a name and email (optional), type the number shown, enter a comment, click Add.
Note that you can leave the name blank if you want to remain anonymous.
Enter your email address to receive notifications of replies and updates to this entry.
Note that your IP address will be stored and you will be blocked if you misuse this system.
The comment should appear immediately because the authorisation system is currently inactive.



I do podcasts too! You can listen to my latest podcast, here: OJB's Podcast 2026-10-29 Thirteen Channels: I had not 13, but 32 channels of shit on the TV to choose from. Or subscribe to my podcast RSS feed, on my RSS Feeds page.

If you're not sure what to view from the thousands of pages on my site, here are some suggestions: My Latest Airshow Report (photos and movies from Warbirds Over Wanaka, 2026), My Favourite Wines and Beers (tasting notes for some of my favourites), An Interesting Astronomical Observation (learn a bit about astronomy from these observing notes), See Some Photos (a short rail journey through the Taieri Gorge), Read Some Mac Tips (learn about how to use your Mac, and fix some problems).


Latest Site News and Notifications (Desktop): You are currently viewing OJB's web site, version 2.4 which has some major changes, and possibly errors! Please report any problems to ojb@mac.com.

 Site ©2026 by OJBWeb ServerMicrosoft Free ZoneMade & Served on Mac 
Site Features: Blog RSS Feeds Podcasts Feedback Log02 May 2026. Hits: 1,232,103,143
Description: Blog PageKeywords: BlogLoad Timer: 18ms